Aligning E-Commerce and Brick-and-Mortar Sales Incentives
By Seth Sarelson, [email protected]
In 2009, Terry Lundgren, the CEO of Macy’s, gave the keynote address at Shop.org, discussing how “the power of e-commerce extends far beyond the keyboard and right onto the sales floor.” Lundgren went on to say that Macy’s believes that $5 billion of in-store sales is influenced by the Internet.
This belief is consistent with many studies showing that consumers frequently engage with digital media, go to a retailer’s website to pre-shop online and then make a purchase in the retailer’s physical store.
Despite knowledge of this behavior, many retailers have been slow to link online advertising with sales on the brick-and-mortar floor. There are a number of reasons why the retail industry has been reticent to connect online marketing and offline sales, chief among them the inability to properly attribute a purchase back to the marketing activity that drove it.
Based on our own observations at RevTrax, where we work with hundreds of retailers to link online advertising with offline sales, we see retailers struggle with this attribution issue every day. This struggle is most often due to a fundamental disconnect between a retailer’s brick & mortar operations and its e-commerce operations.
The origin of this disconnect dates back a common retail practice of late 90’s. With the rise of ecommerce, many companies built silos to varying degrees — creating a separate entity for the ecommerce division, housing the ecommerce division in a different city or even licensing the rights to their ecommerce property to a third party.
Further isolating ecommerce from brick-and-mortar was the era’s prevailing wisdom that digital marketing was reserved for the influence of online sales. Retailers assigned marketing talent either to e-commerce or brick-and-mortar, but rarely to both. Relationships with the burgeoning digital marketing community, including agencies and myriad technology vendors, were also usually the domain of the ecommerce division.
Today we find ourselves in a situation where most of the sophisticated digital marketing expertise, operational knowledge of digital media, and relationships with digital media vendors reside with retailers’ e-commerce teams. In a true multichannel age, this digital divide is a tremendous organizational challenge that is impacting retail organizations of every size. Even as the more forward-thinking retailers redistribute talent and resources within their organizations to leverage digital media as a driver of offline sales, serious attribution issues remain. Given the retail sector’s lack of online and offline integration over the last two decades, few digital marketers or digital media vendors have tried to answer granular questions like: What metrics should be used to quantify the impact of an online ad on an in-store sale? How would you adjust a display ad manager’s compensation model to reward an in-store sale?
So how does this all get fixed?
Step 1: Senior level buy into multichannel strategy
Top executives must agree that channels do not operate in silos. They must begin to reorganize, shifting corporate culture as necessary to address the new multichannel world in which we live. It’s a tremendous undertaking, but change needs to start at the top.
Step 2: Knowledge sharing
Mangers responsible for e-commerce and in-store sales need to be physically located in the same place in order to work together to share best practices, industry contacts and develop a collaborative relationship.
Step 3: Change organizational incentives
Managers who are responsible for digital media should get credit for both online and offline sales resulting from their efforts.
Step 4: Use right methods and metrics
In order to effectively measure the impact of digital media on offline sales, managers should investigate a variety of new tools and technology to connect the digital and physical worlds. Using the right technology and key metrics for measurement are critical for proper attribution.
Step 5: Test, test and test again
With change comes uncertainly, which is why it’s critical to try new approaches to connect digital to in-store sales, measure results and then refine these approaches.
The convergence of online and offline is perhaps the most exciting time for the industry since the advent of e-commerce. We’ve seen time and again that organizations unwilling to make the tough choices to transform to new realties often become relics of a bygone era. Retailers that act now, both from a cultural and organizational standpoint and from a measurement, marketing and technology standpoint, will be best suited to address the new era of multichannel marketing.
Seth Sarelson is COO at RevTrax, a New York City based provider of technology solutions to measure the impact of digital media on in-store sales. He can be reached at [email protected] or visit RevTrax.com.
More Web Exclusives/Guest Commentaries
Tractor Supply passes billion-dollar barrier in first quarter
Reacting quickly to an early spring, Brentwood, Tenn.-based Tractor Supply Co. said its first-quarter sales increased 22% to $1.02 billion.
Same-store sales for the quarter increased 11.5%. The country’s largest farm-and-ranch retailer, which will release its full first-quarter earnings results April 25, said the same-store sales increase was driven, in part, by early spring weather in 2012.
"We are delighted to have achieved record first-quarter sales in excess of $1 billion for the first time in Tractor Supply’s history, with favorable customer response to our spring assortments and ongoing merchandising enhancements,” said CEO Jim Wright. “The structural improvements we have made to our business in recent years have enabled us to adapt our assortments more readily to meet consumer demand and react quickly to take advantage of events, such as the early spring weather seen in March.”
Based on strong results in the first quarter, Tractor Supply raised its financial expectations for 2012. Net sales are now expected to range between $4.61 billion and $4.68 billion compared with the company’s previously expected range of $4.56 billion to $4.66 billion. Same-store sales for the full year are now expected to increase 4.0% to 5.5% compared with the prior expectation for an increase of 3% to 5%. Net income is now expected to range between $260 million and $265 million compared with the prior expectation of $246 million to $253 million.
Jimmy Choo CEO named president of Bergdorf Goodman
DALLAS — Neiman Marcus Group announced that Joshua Schulman has been appointed president of Bergdorf Goodman, effective May 7.
Schulman, 40, joins Neiman Marcus from Jimmy Choo where he was CEO. In this role, he oversaw the international expansion of the brand and the growth of jimmychoo.com. Prior to Jimmy Choo, Schulman was president, Kenneth Cole New York, and managing director, international strategic alliances, Gap Inc.
"Bergdorf Goodman is the pinnacle of luxury retailing, and is known world-wide for its signature style and modern sophistication," said Karen Katz, president and CEO of The Neiman Marcus Group Inc. "Joshua’s unique experience blends keen business acumen with creativity and vision. He appreciates the legacy of Bergdorf Goodman but understands brands have to be continually defined and re-defined. From merchandising to marketing to sales and service, he is exceptional in his ability to bring an idea and an ideal to life. He is the perfect leader for Bergdorf Goodman."