News

The Present and Future Landscape of Consumer Privacy Litigation

BY CSA STAFF

By Amy Lally and Leah Abeles, Sidley Austin LLP

A number of recent class actions highlight three California privacy laws that were rarely litigated a decade ago. Last month, courts in California approved settlements by Big 5 (In re Big 5 Sporting Goods Song-Beverly Cases) and Lululemon (Chaikin v. Lululemon USA Inc.) in California Song-Beverly Credit Card Act (the “Credit Card Act”) cases. In both cases, the retailers agreed to issue vouchers to a class of consumers who claimed their personal identifying information (“PII”) was collected when they paid by credit card.

The Credit Card Act prohibits retailers from recording consumers’ PII during credit card transactions. This includes collection of ZIP codes, email addresses and phone numbers. Some exceptions allow retailers to request PII for specific purposes such as shipping or fraud prevention.

In addition to the Credit Card Act, a spate of consumer class actions have been filed under the California Invasion of Privacy Act (“CIPA”), as well as the Shine the Light law (“STL”). While the Credit Card Act generally applies at the point of sale, CIPA more frequently comes into play during customer service calls. Among other things, CIPA prohibits certain phone calls from being recorded without consent. The STL, meanwhile, requires that businesses disclose, upon request, third party marketers with whom the company has shared a customer’s PII.

Although none of these statutory schemes are new, they had generated relatively few consumer lawsuits when enacted, perhaps because they are comparatively obscure state statutes. The recent increase in putative class litigation under these statutes can be attributed in part to the general proliferation of consumer class actions, and in part to increasing attention to privacy issues resulting from continuing advances in technology. Now, it appears the plaintiffs’ bar has discovered these actions can often generate lucrative settlements, including generous attorneys’ fee payouts.

For this reason and others, it is unlikely that such actions will abate, despite several recent court decisions favorable to retailers. In February 2013, for example, the California Supreme Court (Apple Inc. v. Super. Ct.) held that the Credit Card Act does not apply to online transactions for downloadable content. This decision represented a major victory for e-merchandise retailers and led at least one other court (Ambers v. Buy.com, Inc.) to determine that the Credit Card Act does not apply to any online purchases.

However, this triumph for e-retailers may be short-lived, as the California Legislature is poised to amend the Credit Card Act in response to the Apple decision. The proposed legislation, California Senate Bill No. 383, would bring online transactions for downloadable products within the Act’s scope, but would permit online retailers to collect certain PII if necessary to detect fraud or enforce the terms of sale, or if the customer opts in following certain disclosures. If the amendment passes, it will likely generate additional lawsuits against online retailers, especially until courts have had the opportunity to delimit the exceptions permitting PII collection.

In the realm of CIPA litigation, a California appellate court recently upheld a decision denying class certification in Hataishi v. First Am. Home Buyers Protection Corp. Under the law which prohibits recording “confidential communications” without consent, a consumer must have an objectively reasonable expectation that their call will not be recorded. The court held determining each customer’s reasonable expectation depended on the particular circumstances of her call with the defendant, including whether she was advised during past calls that her calls were being recorded. The court also said that a class could not be certified under section of the law which prohibits intercepting cell phone communications because a jury would have to resolve on a call-by-call basis whether the customer was using a cell phone.

While the Hataishi decision raises the question whether a CIPA claim could ever be appropriate for class treatment, it is unlikely to stem the tide of consumer privacy class actions if plaintiffs’ lawyers believe they can survive a motion to dismiss and then settle before having to litigate class certification. This is underscored by the recent decision in McCabe v. Six Continents Hotels, Inc., which denied a motion to dismiss a claim under section 632.7 based on a broad view of the statute’s intent requirement.

Retailers may have better success under the STL, however. A series of recent California court decisions (Boorstein v. CBS Interactive, King v. Conde Nast, Miller v. Hearst) solidified that a plaintiff must request or attempt to request information from the defendant before he has standing to bring an STL claim.

While putative class litigation under the Credit Card Act and CIPA appears likely to continue, retailers can identify steps to mitigate their exposure to such claims by keeping abreast of new developments in consumer privacy law, especially as the proliferation of class actions continues to generate new rulings and legislation.

Amy Lally is a partner and Leah Abeles is an associate in Sidley Austin LLP’s Los Angeles office. The views expressed in this article are exclusively those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of Sidley Austin LLP and its partners. Amy Lally can be reached at [email protected] and Leah Abeles can be reached at [email protected].


More Web Exclusives/Guest Commentaries

keyboard_arrow_downCOMMENTS

Leave a Reply

No comments found

TRENDING STORIES

Polls

Are you hiring seasonal employees this year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
News

Domino’s accepts Google Wallet payments

BY Dan Berthiaume

Ann Arbor, Mich. – Domino’s Pizza is integrating Google Wallet with its Android ordering app. Domino’s customers who have an Android device can now pay for their online orders using Google’s digital wallet.

Domino’s customers who place an online order of $10 or more using the Android ordering app and pay by selecting the "Buy with Google" button at checkout will receive a free order of Domino’s new specialty chicken, now through June 15.

"This is yet another way Domino’s is using technology to improve our customer experience," said Patrick Doyle, Domino’s Pizza president and CEO. "Google Wallet is a great technology that allows customers even more flexibility and convenience when it comes to paying for their Domino’s orders."

keyboard_arrow_downCOMMENTS

Leave a Reply

S.Scott says:
May-03-2014 02:44 am

Near-field communication (NFC) technology permits a consumer to wave their mobile phone at a point-of-sale terminal to buy via the use of a “digital wallet.” One of the fast-growing instances of the digital wallet is the appropriately known as Google Wallet, but it pays to know just a little bit about how it works before you dive in to the cashless (and cardless) retail revolution. Article source: Personal Finance?

S.Scott says:
May-03-2014 02:44 am

Near-field communication (NFC) technology permits a consumer to wave their mobile phone at a point-of-sale terminal to buy via the use of a “digital wallet.” One of the fast-growing instances of the digital wallet is the appropriately known as Google Wallet, but it pays to know just a little bit about how it works before you dive in to the cashless (and cardless) retail revolution. Article source: Personal Finance?

TRENDING STORIES

Polls

Are you hiring seasonal employees this year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
News

Campbell’s hires Walmart’s social exec

BY CSA STAFF

Umang Shah was named global director for social media and digital marketing at Campbell’s after serving in a similar capacity at Walmart for the past two years.

Ad Age reported that Shah will start at Campbell on April 28 after holding the position of director of social media strategy at Walmart for the past two years. Prior to that he served as a social media strategist at Microsoft. His responsibilities at Campbell will include leading mobile and emerging media activation in paid, owned and earned media channels and he will report to the soup company’s vp of integrated marketing Yin Rani.

Shah’s departure from Walmart comes as the retailer loses Marc Rosen as SVP of global e-commerce at Walmart to Levi Strauss & Co. Levi hired Rosen to service as president of global e-commerce effective May 5.

keyboard_arrow_downCOMMENTS

Leave a Reply

No comments found

TRENDING STORIES

Polls

Are you hiring seasonal employees this year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...