News

RILA Debunks Op-Ed Piece on Marketplace Fairness Act

BY CSA STAFF

The Retail Industry Leaders Association (RILA) has taken issue with an opinion piece that appears in the August 1, 2012, issue of the Wall Street Journal. The piece, written by United States Senator Jim DeMint (R-SC), is about the Marketplace Fairness Act (the legislation would end special treatment for online-only retailers who currently exploit a decade’s old loophole to avoid collecting and remitting state sales tax, according to RILA). The article includes a number of factual errors or “myths,” RILA claims, and it has produced the following document to highlight the inaccuracies.

The Myths: “The Marketplace Fairness Act recently introduced in the Senate would require online retailers to collect and pay sales taxes to states where they have no physical presence or democratic recourse. Overstock.com, eBay and the like could have to pay sales taxes to any state from which an Internet user placed an order.”
The Facts: “Pay” is misleading; the retailer simply remits taxes collected from the consumer.

The Myths: “Such online sales tax proposals are taxation without representation.”
The Facts: False. The tax is imposed by the state to which the goods are shipped. The consumer in that state pays the tax and ordinarily has a vote in that state (except for felons, tourists, etc.).

The Myths: “The Supreme Court ruled (in Quill Corp. v. North Dakota, 1992) that retailers can be required to collect sales taxes only in states where they have a physical presence.”
The Facts: The Court further said “… that the underlying issue is not only one that Congress may be better qualified to resolve, but also one that Congress has the ultimate power to resolve.”

The Myths: Consider the absurdity of such a law. When a customer buys a product in a store, does the cashier ask for the customer’s home address? Of course not. The store simply charges the state and local sales taxes applicable for its physical location, no questions asked.

“The proposed law would hold online sellers to an entirely different standard. Websites would have to add taxes to a sale based on the shipping destination of the product, which may be a state in which neither the seller nor the buyer resides. We would never ask mom-and-pop store owners to do such a thing.”
The Facts: For over the counter sales, the point of delivery is the counter. For other sales—whether online or not, whether large retailers or “mom and pop” stores—it is the destination to which the goods are shipped. All sellers are treated the same for tax collection purposes, except that remote sellers currently enjoy a federal exemption from collection.

The Myths: “Politicians want this bill passed to raise new tax revenue for broken state governments facing budget shortfalls. But legislators in state capitals don’t want to make the hard decisions to cut spending or raise taxes on their constituents—they fear the voter backlash.”
The Facts: States across the political spectrum continue to act far more fiscally prudent than the federal government. They have made hard decisions to cut spending; during the current recession, state and local government employment has dropped significantly, but federal government employment has continued to increase. State lawmakers have made and will continue to make tough choices. With regard to sales tax collection, state legislators have no choice but to turn to Congress. As the Court has said, Congress has the ultimate authority in this area.

The Myths: “At its core, this is a nationally mandated Internet sales tax on businesses.”
The Facts: False. Each state would maintain its own sales tax system, or continue to choose to impose no sales tax at all. Residents in states without a sales tax would continue to shop “tax free” on the internet and on main street. Residents in states with a sales tax would pay exactly what they owe today, not a penny more.

Read the complete statement by RILA.


More Retail Insights

keyboard_arrow_downCOMMENTS

Leave a Reply

J.Hams says:
Dec-12-2012 05:41 am

The Facts: False. Each state would maintain its own sales tax system, or continue to choose to impose no sales tax at all. Residents in states without a sales tax would continue to shop “tax free” on the internet and on main street. Residents in states with a sales tax would pay exactly what they owe today, not a penny more. sheep shearing

J.Hams says:
Dec-12-2012 05:41 am

The Facts: False. Each state would maintain its own sales tax system, or continue to choose to impose no sales tax at all. Residents in states without a sales tax would continue to shop “tax free” on the internet and on main street. Residents in states with a sales tax would pay exactly what they owe today, not a penny more. sheep shearing

TRENDING STORIES

Polls

Are you hiring seasonal employees this year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
News

Old Navy, OfficeMax teach BTS lesson in collaboration

BY CSA STAFF

NAPERVILLE, Ill. — With new clothes and supplies topping the list of what most parents are shopping for during back-to-school season, it makes sense that OfficeMax and Old Navy would join forces to maximize their offerings, delivering savings for customers and sales for them.

Through Aug. 15, OfficeMax back-to-school customers will receive a register receipt coupon for $10 off a $50 purchase at Old Navy stores nationwide. The coupon can be redeemed at Old Navy stores through Aug. 22. Additionally, Old Navy shoppers will receive a coupon at checkout good for $10 off a $40 purchase at OfficeMax stores nationwide or online at officemax.com through Sept. 30.

"We’re continuously seeking ways to support our customers and provide additional value," said Michael Lewis, OfficeMax EVP, president of retail. "Through this collaboration, OfficeMax and Old Navy are helping consumers buy more for less this back-to-school season. Trendy supplies and fashionable apparel at great savings – it’s a shopping trip both parents and students will enjoy."

“We love outfitting our customers for back-to-school,” said Michelle DeMartini, SVP Old Navy adult merchandising and brand licensing. “With OfficeMax’s help, Old Navy families can top off their attire with school supply ‘accessories’ at value prices. We want our shoppers to feel fully prepared for the new school year.”

keyboard_arrow_downCOMMENTS

Leave a Reply

No comments found

TRENDING STORIES

Polls

Are you hiring seasonal employees this year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
News

POS provider earns industry award

BY CSA STAFF

LASVEGAS — Epson America Inc., a supplier of value-added Point of Sale (POS) solutions, has received the Gold Award of Excellence in the hardware technology category during the RetailSolutions Providers Association’s RetailNOW 2012 show.

"We are so honored our dealers have awarded Epson the gold award three years in a row now," said Jeff Burroughs, national channel sales manager for Epson America System Device Group. "We’ve always been strong supporters of the channel, and we highly value each and every partner out there selling our solutions."

Epson is a certified, long-standing member of the RSPA. The RSPA Certification Program identifies companies in the retail technology industry who provide exceptional levels of competence and performance in a professional manner.RetailNOW is the retail technology industry’s largest cross-vertical show, including leading vendors and distributors in grocery, food service, convenience and retail verticals.

keyboard_arrow_downCOMMENTS

Leave a Reply

No comments found

TRENDING STORIES

Polls

Are you hiring seasonal employees this year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...